MENGELBERG Beethoven: Symphonies 2 & 8, Fidelio Overture (1940) - PASC229

This album is included in the following sets:

MENGELBERG Beethoven: Symphonies 2 & 8, Fidelio Overture (1940) - PASC229

Regular price €0.00 €15.00 Sale

CDs are produced to order and are normally shipped within 3-5 working days.

Regular price €0.00 €10.00 Sale

  • Sold Out! - CD with case & artwork (+MP3)


BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 2
BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 8
BEETHOVEN Fidelio Overture
Recorded live in 1940, Amsterdam
Total duration: 71:09

Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
conductor Willem Mengelberg

This set contains the following albums:

More superb Beethoven from Willem Mengelberg

Utterly astonishing XR-remastered sound quality

Willem Mengelberg and the Concertgebouw Orchestra were recorded on a number of occasions by AVRO using high quality glass acetate discs, which produced significantly better results than those normally obtained by shellac discs of the era, with a much wider dynamic and frequency range than was usual at the time.

Many of Mengelberg's AVRO recordings have long been available on LP and, later, CD, and their sonic advantages have been immediately clear to listeners for decades.

However, using standard flat replay systems to produce those LPs and CDs has only told perhaps half of the story - the recordings gently rolled off both higher and lower frequencies. Howver, these essential details are often still intact, buried in the recordings as if awaiting a remastering method capable of extracting them and restoring their original levels.

This is, of course, precisely what Pristine's XR remastering system excels at. There are extended sections in both 1940 concert recordings present here where we've been able to present a true full-frequency, 20-20,000 Hz frequency response, coupled with a dynamic range more befitting of a 1960s or 1970s analogue recording - sound quality which is quite astonishing for its age.

Elsewhere the bottom end has seen considerable improvement, with a much fuller and richer sound than originally heard in the flat transfers. The use of multiple references for the remastering of the recordings has ensured that the tonal balance is as natural and realistic as possible, and that the two recordings resulted in an orchestral sound which was consistent for both recordings. One will rarely get closer to hearing a 1940 concert than this.

These transfers
The discs which originally held the present recordings were variable in condition, and at times quite extensive repair work has been necessary in order to remove or reduce bumps, clicks, scratches, swish and high-end noise. In order to maintain as much musical information as possible there is therefore some small variation in background noise, though I've tried to retain smooth progressions between the various sections of the recordings so this does not jar. Overall the sound is once again amazing for its vintage - despite repeated listening I remain astonished at what was achieved in 1940 and what I've been able to extract and reveal in these superlative recordings.

 Andrew Rose

  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 2 in D major, Opus 36
    Concert of 21st April, 1940

  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 8 in F major, Opus 93
    Concert of 18th April, 1940

  • BEETHOVEN Fidelio Overture, Op. 72c
    Concert variously attributed to April 28th or October 13th, 1940

    Played by Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
    conductor Willem Mengelberg

    Recorded in April/October 1940 at the Concertgebouw, by AVRO Radio
    Transfers from Philips LPs 6597 010 and 6597 009 in the Pristine collection
    XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, May-June 2010
    Cover artwork based on a photograph of Willem Mengelberg at the Concertgebouw

    Total duration: 71:09 

Pristine's Review

Another truly exceptional disc from Pristine. Keep ’em coming!

Andrew Rose continues to work his restorative magic on Mengelberg’s wartime performances, and the results are again revelatory in terms of improvements in dynamic range and presence, far outclassing previous CD releases from Music & Arts and Philips. I have one small reservation: The Pristine transfers are perhaps very slightly over-filtered in the quietest passages, occasionally resulting in a “disappearing” effect at the extreme end of the dynamic range. A case in point is the diminuendo to ppp before the crashing forte C♯ near the beginning of the finale of No. 8—the Philips sounds a little more natural here, through its heavy acetate crackle. But in every other respect, the superiority is Pristine’s all the way.

No. 2 is played for clarity, at deliberate tempos, with weighty precision. The first movement (complete with exposition repeat) has a remarkable sharpness of focus, with a fanatical concern to make every note count (e.g., the amazing fullness and breadth achieved in the descending figure in cellos and basses at bars 88 ff.). Mengelberg’s refusal to hurry this movement is altogether a far cry from the impulsive dash of Krauss (VPO, 1929/Preiser) or the extrovert assertiveness of Beecham (LPO, 1936/Beecham Collection), closer to the pliable, richly detailed approach of Kleiber (Berlin State Opera Orchestra, 1929/Dutton Labs or Naxos). The Larghetto is slow (12:33), played with great freedom and immense care over detail (hear the singing second theme, bars 48 ff., and the “speaking” quality of the strings/wind interchanges at 66 ff.). In the main theme of the finale, Mengelberg’s obsession with clarity of articulation might be thought to court pedantry. The controlled rigor of the approach culminates in a coda of ferocious, crushing power.

Interestingly, Toscanini takes a similarly weightier than usual approach in his 1939 cycle (Music & Arts), a performance of great intensity and élan, though less nuance than the Dutch maestro. Fascinating, too, to hear Mengelberg in another live version from three years later (1943/Tahra), now taking an altogether less extreme view of the work, notably faster and lighter.

The first movement of No. 8 has an exceptionally trenchant force and clarity, combining extreme rhythmic and phrase-structural precision with huge tempo flexibility in the secondary and closing material. Mengelberg radically lightens the dense textures of the minuet, imparting a rare degree of real dance lift. The finale is a miracle of refinement and precision at its moderate tempo, with plenty of time for the attention to detail to speak (and quite a contrast with Toscanini’s fierce, clipped approach in 1939, at a tempo uniquely—for its time—close to Beethoven’s metronome mark). For one small example, hear his dramatically enhanced timing of the deceptive chromatic resolutions at bars 48 and 224, setting the scene for the payoff of playing it straight at the motive’s third appearance (bar 408), where it finally resolves to the tonic—Mengelberg was ever the musician’s musician, for all his penchant for outsize gestures.

The performance of the Fidelio Overture is decades ahead of its time in lightness, verve, and sheer coruscating brilliance, anticipating the period-performance movement in its rhythmic snap (hear the Allegro’s main horn theme, the notes briskly clipped for maximum airiness and punch).

Another truly exceptional disc from Pristine. Keep ’em coming!

Boyd Pomeroy

This article originally appeared in Issue 34:3 (Jan/Feb 2011) of Fanfare Magazine.