SCHILLINGS conducts Beethoven, Schumann and Weber (1928/29) - PASC228

This album is included in the following sets:

SCHILLINGS conducts Beethoven, Schumann and Weber (1928/29) - PASC228

Regular price €0.00 €9.00 Sale

CDs are produced to order and are normally shipped within 3-5 working days.

Regular price €0.00 €10.00 Sale

  • Sold Out! - CD with case & artwork (+MP3)


WEBER Two Overtures
SCHUMANN Manfred - excerpts
BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 6 'Pastoral'
Recorded in 1928 and 1929
Total duration: 77:59

Berlin State Opera Orchestra
conducted by Max von Schillings

This set contains the following albums:

A superb range of early Romantic works conducted by Schillings

Teacher of Furtwängler, composer and conductor, in excellent new transfers

The few CD reissues devoted to recordings of Max von Schillings which have appeared so far have concentrated on his justly-acclaimed Wagner performances, as well as those of his own compositions (Mona Lisa, Das Hexenlied). This release aims to broaden our appreciation of his abilities with a program of early Romantic repertoire.

The sources for the transfers were American Columbia “Viva-Tonal” pressings for the Weber items; American “Okeh” Odeons (also pressed by American Columbia during their “Viva-Tonal” period) for the Schumann tracks; a pre-EMI laminated British Parlophone for the Egmont; and Italian Parlophon pressings (with a couple patches from a German Odeon set) for the Pastoral Symphony. Although the original engineering was not state-of-the-art for its time, the recordings from the 1928-29 season appear to have less overloading and blasting than the symphony, taken down the following season.

Mark Obert-Thorn

  • WEBER Euryanthe - Overture (8:48)
    Recorded 8th October, 1928 in Berlin
    Matrix nos.: 2-20991 through 2-20993
    First issued on Parlophon P-9848 and 9849

  • WEBER Abu Hassan - Overture (3:27)
    Recorded 19th December, 1928 in Berlin
    Matrix no.: 2-21137
    First issued on Parlophon P-9849

  • SCHUMANN Manfred, Op. 115 - Overture
  • SCHUMANN Manfred, Op. 115 - Alpenkuhreigen und Zwischenaktmusik* (3:59)
    Recorded 3rd May and *10th May, 1929 in Berlin
    Matrix nos.: 2-21393 through 2-21395, and *2-21406
    First issued on Parlophon P-9484 and 9485

  • BEETHOVEN Egmont, Op. 84 - Overture (8:01)
    Recorded 14th December, 1928 in Berlin
    Matrix nos.: 2-21126 and 2-21127
    First issued on Parlophon P-9456

  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 6 in F Major, Op. 68 (“Pastoral”) (42:50)
    Recorded 16th, 23rd and 30th September, 1929 in Berlin
    Matrix nos.: 2-21560 through 2-21566; 2-21572 and 2-21573; and 2-21586 through 2-21588
    First issued on Parlphon P-9463 through 9468

    Berlin State Opera Orchestra
    conducted by Max von Schillings

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer: Mark Obert-Thorn
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Max von Schillings

Total duration: 77:59

Fanfare Review

The playing is of high quality, Schillings’s conducting natural and unforced

This is one of Pristine’s most enterprising releases to date. Max von Schillings, better known as a composer in his day, was not a very prolific recording artist, and as a conductor has until now been remembered mainly (if at all) for his Wagner orchestral excerpts, available on Preiser. Release of these early electricals (1928–29) restores to availability a very important document in the early discography of Beethoven’s symphonies.

Anyone coming to this release with expectations of Kapellmeister-ish efficiency (as I confess I did) will be agreeably surprised to encounter music-making of much vitality and considerable interpretive individuality. The orchestra’s light sound—vibrato-free strings and lean winds—is very effective for the “Pastoral.” The playing is of high quality, Schillings’s conducting natural and unforced, flexible in pulse (especially in the first-movement development, “Scene by the Brook,” and “Shepherd’s Hymn”), but with fine forward momentum. His large-scale shaping is unerring, adding up to a very satisfying experience. (I’ll also note, once again, that the tuba reinforcing the basses was quite unnecessary in 1929, four years into the electric era; in this instance, however, he really earned his money, frantically joining in the 16th-notes in the “Storm”—hearing is believing!)

Comparing with other early electrical versions, it is interesting to observe Schillings steering a middle course between his compatriots Pfitzner (with the same orchestra, in the same year, on Naxos or Preiser) and Schalk (VPO, 1928/Lys): Pfitzner is very slow, bucolic, less flexible in tempo and less well played, but memorably rustic in the “Scene by the Brook” (his 14:00 sounding slower than Schillings’s even more leisurely, but more flexibly varied, 14:38), and with a very exciting “Storm” and deeply devotional “Shepherd’s Hymn.” Schalk, in contrast, is swift, buoyant, and elegant—almost a proto-period-instrument approach, with the 1920s VPO in incredibly characterful form. Weingartner (RPO, 1927/Naxos) is brisk, objective, and comparatively uninflected (dispatching the “Scene by the Brook” in a no-nonsense 10:56!), with the London orchestra notably inferior to both Berlin and Vienna.

Schillings’s Egmont is dramatically conceived and well shaped, though with playing less disciplined than in the symphony (less disciplined, in fact, than Nikisch’s rivetingly dramatic acoustic version with the LSO in 1913! [Symposium]). Enjoyable, but not much real contest with other early electrical classics from Mengelberg (NYPO, 1930/Pearl or Naxos—superb élan, thrust, and elegance) and Furtwängler (BPO, 1933/Koch or Naxos—darkly massive).

The Weber overtures are a delight, ideally light and airborne. As for Schumann’s Manfred, this 1929 recording is by far the earliest known to me (does anyone know of one earlier?). The performance is strikingly classical, swift, spirited, and transparent in texture (if not ideally refined)—not unlike Schuricht’s punchy 1946 version with the LSO (Lys, though in poor sound), and quite a contrast with the organ-like bronzed romantic splendor of Abendroth (Leipzig Gewandhaus, 1944/Tahra).

Mark Obert-Thorn’s transfers are well up to his usual standards. Altogether an important release, whetting the appetite for Schillings’s remaining recordings, including an “Eroica,” “Unfinished,” and Also sprach Zarathustra. Any chance, Pristine?

Boyd Pomeroy

This article originally appeared in Issue 34:2 (Nov/Dec 2010) of Fanfare Magazine.