Back to Top


Tosca - Puccini - PACO047

Availability: Immediate download


* Required Fields

Tosca - Puccini - PACO047 -CD
Bookmark and Share


Carmen Melis
Piero Pauli
Apollo Granforte
Full list of soloists below
Orchestra and Chorus of La Scala, Milan
conducted by Carlo Sabajno

Studio recording from 1929-30

Recorded in Milan, 1929-30, issued as HMV C1920-1915
Transferred and remastered by Ward Marston, May-June 2010
Conver artwork based on a photograph of Granforte as Scarpio, early 1930s

Total duration: 1hr 47:06
©2010 Pristine Audio.


Sabajno's classic 1929 Tosca - one of the all-time greats

Superb new high-quality transfer by Ward Marston


  • PUCCINI - Tosca [notes / score]

    Tosca - Carmen Melis [s]
    Cavaradossi - Piero Pauli [t]
    Scarpia - Apollo Granforte [b]
    Angelotti - Giovanni Azzimonti [b]
    Il Sagrestano - Antonio Gelli [bs]
    Spoletta - Nello Palai [t]
    Sciarrone - Giovanni Azzimonti [b]
    Shepherd Boy - Uncredited

    Orchestra and Chorus of La Scala, Milan
    Conducted by Carlo Sabajno
    Chorus Master, Vittore Veneziani

    (Two sides were conducted by Gino Nastrucci)

Source information:

Recorded Milan, 1929-1930, by Italian HMV on 28 sides, issued HMV Plum Label C1902-1915
Matrices: CM 1244-2, 21 November 1929; CM 1222-2, 12 November 1929 CM 1229-2, 15 November 1929 CM 1213-2, 7 november 1929 CM 1216-3, 14 January 1930 CM 1232-2, 18 November 1929 CM 1230-2, 15 November 1929 CM 1234-2, 19 November 1929 CM 1203-2, 5 November 1929 CM 1204-4, 22 November 1929 CM 1223-2, 12 November 1929 CM 1267-2, 27 November 1929 CM 1268-3, 27 November 1929 CM 1249-1, 22 November 1929 CM 1240-1, 20 November 1929 CM 1241-2, 20 November 1929 CM 1242-2, 20 November 1929 CM 1212-5, 28 February 1929 (Nastrucci cond.) CM 1217-1, 9 November 1929 CM 1243-1, 21 November 1929 CM 1235-3, 19 November 1929 CM 1261-3, 26 November 1929 CM 1226-4, 24 March 1930 CM 1224-3, 14 November 1929 CM 1227-1, 14 November 1929 CM 1219-1, 11 November 1929 CM 1221-4, 14 January 1930 CM 1250-2, 22 November 1929

CD, MP3 and FLAC information:

CDs: Double set - Act 1 = CD1, Acts 2 & 3 = CD2.

FLACs: Continuous tracks with a short pause between acts.

MP3: Two MP3s in a Zip filed which correspond to the two CDs as outlined above, complete with individual cue sheets

Please check our help section for help with FLAC, MP3, Cue and Zip files. Downloads also include PDF files with printable covers and JPG files with front cover artwork, which is also embedded into individual music files.


"...To go serially, through the fourteen double-sided records (Nos. C1902-1915) would involve the repetition of an oft-told tale. Suffice it to say that the calibre of the workmanship and artistry revealed in them is of the highest order. Consequently, there is no need for comparisons. I cannot perceive any shortcomings either in the interpretation of the score or the quality of the recording. Each scene stands out clearly, strongly, effectively; and let me add that the necessary interruptions or divisions have been extremely well devised. It should, therefore, be easy to provide with this material a thoroughly realistic and comprehensible musical representation of Puccini's opera..."

From "THE H.M.V. ALBUM OF "TOSCA" by Herman Klein in The Gramophone, July 1930


Technical notes:

This recording of Puccini’s Tosca features the highly regarded dramatic soprano, Carmen Melis (1885-1957) in her only electric recording, and her only complete opera on disc.  She studied with Jean de Reszke and made her operatic debut in 1905 as Thais.  Over her 30 year career, Tosca was one of her most important roles, and one for which she was duly praised.   Heard here also is the incomparable Apollo Granforte (1886-1975) as Scarpia, whose portrayal of the role is still considered perhaps the best on record. The conducting of Carlo Sabajno, 1874-1938, is up to his usual high standard of excellence.  Tenor, Piero Pauli, is sadly this recording’s only disappointment. His unattractive treatment of Cavaradossi’s music is all too evident, and his unappealing vocal timbre is often accentuated by his proximity to the microphone. The sonic quality of the recording is amazingly vivid for its time, especially for the orchestra. The voices too are well-recorded except during the most intense passages where the recording equipment was not capable of handling the high levels.  During these moments, there occurs severe distortion which is only slightly remediable.
The present transfer was made using three excellent condition sets, pressed during the mid-1930s on quiet Z-shellac by U.S. RCA Victor. For each side, I chose the best of the three, but often patched short problematic passages from the other two copies. 

Since this recording was made over a number of sessions spanning four months, the sound obtained on some days was definitely superior to sound from other sessions.  In order to achieve the best possible sound, each side was tested using a variety of stylus sizes and shapes. I used CEDAR declicking and decrackling, but did not use any digital denoising.

Ward Marston
June 2010



Find out more:



CD covers to print:
NB. Covers are designed for a single 2CD case.


PACO047 cover

CD-writing cuesheet (save as .cue):
(Use this to split MP3 files - see here)


Download our Full Discography
Printable text listings of all Pristine Audio historic releases
XR remastering by Andrew Rose:
Pristine Audio


Use spaces to separate tags. Use single quotes (') for phrases.


Only registered users can write reviews. Please, log in or register

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more here.