Back to Top


Cantelli's 26th NBC Concert: Vivaldi and Brahms - PASC237

Availability: In stock

Cantelli's 26th NBC Concert: Vivaldi and Brahms - PASC237-CD

* Required Fields

Bookmark and Share

Quick Overview

NBC Symphony Orchestra
conductor Guido Cantelli
Recorded live in 1952, New York City

Live NBC broadcast from Carnegie Hall, 6th December, 1952
Transfer tape from the collection of Keith Bennett
XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, August 2010
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Guido Cantelli

Total duration: 57:48
©2010 Pristine Audio.


Superb concert recording from Toscanini's 'anointed' successor

Crowned by a marvellous Brahms 1st - in superb sound quality throughout


  • VIVALDI Concerto Grosso in A minor, Op.3, No. 8 (from L'Estro Armonico) [notes / score]
    Daniel Guilet, Remo Bolognini, solo violins
  • BRAHMS Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 68 [notes / score]

    Played by NBC Symphony Orchestra
    conductor Guido Cantelli

Live NBC broadcast from Carnegie Hall, 6th December, 1952


Notes on the transfers:

These transfers were taken from a high quality open-reel tape copy preserved by Cantelli specialist and author Keith Bennett, whose comprehensive notes on this concert can be found below, a condensed version of which is also available on the CD cover. The tape preserved a BBC rebroadcast of the concert, which omitted the opening and closing announcements of the original but included Ben Grauer's commentary between the Vivaldi and Brahms. Additional BBC announcements have been removed from this reissue, but Grauer's words have been preserved.

Overall sound quality of the originals was generally excellent for its era, and the recordings have responded very well indeed to XR remastering, producing a fuller and more vivid sound where it had perhaps been just a little flat and overly strident in the upper registers.

Andrew Rose



Full Vivaldi biography:

Full Brahms biography:



Cantelli’s Twenty-sixth Concert with the

NBC Symphony Orchestra - 6 December 1952



Vivaldi: Concerto Grosso for Two Violins, Op.3, No.8

The majority of readers seeing the name of Vivaldi in the programme will not see anyting remarkable in that. However, the first time the writer heard any of this composer’s music was as a 22 year-old: it was in a concert given by Cantelli in the Royal Festival Hall in October 1951 and it was the first time that any Vivaldi had been played in the hall which had been inaugurated the previous May. The NBC Symphony Orchestra came into being at the end of 1937 but, despite the fact that Toscanini included Vivaldi’s Concerto Grosso Op.3, No.11 in his very first concert, the conductor who included the works of Vivaldi in his programmes with this orchestra more often than any other was Guido Cantelli. Although Cantelli gave more concerts with this orchestra (40) than any other conductor apart from Toscanini, he still only gave three of the four works in his repertoire with the orchestra and Vivaldi was only played in six concerts.

Cantelli had conducted this concerto for the first time while still a student in 1942 and his only other performances were both with the NBC Symphony Orchestra: on 15 January 1951 the first-desk soloists were Mischa Mischakoff and Max Hollander but for the performance on this CD (which was his last) the violinists were Daniel Guilet (who had become leader after Mischakoff’s departure) and Remo Bolognini.


Brahms: Symphony in C minor, No.1, Op.68

Toscanini’s last appearances in London were when he conducted two all-Brahms concerts with the Philharmonia Orchestra on 29 September and 1 October 1952 which included all four symphonies and Cantelli was present at rehearsals and the concerts.

Prior to Toscanini’s concerts Cantelli had conducted the Symphony No.1 less than a week earlier just twice (with the Orchestra della Scala on 23 and 24 September). In the following December Cantelli gave his only performance with the NBC Symphony Orchestra and after the concert he and his wife Iris went as usual back to Riverdale (Toscanini’s home) for a meal. The Maestro had enjoyed the performance and on the arrival of his young colleague came forward to congratulate him but was dumbfounded when Cantelli announced that his interpretation ‘was one of the best around’. The meal took place in silence. Cantelli’s outburst was arrogant – after all, this was only his third performance – but to make such a comment to the Maestro who had performed this same symphony in the young conductor’s presence just a few weeks earlier showed a total lack of sensitivity. Ignoring Cantelli’s shortcoming in this particular instance, the irony is that his performances of this symphony were some of the best around and as a record collector the writer prefers not only his commercial performance of 1953 to the two that Toscanini recorded in 1941 and 1951, but also the majority of the live performances by the Maestro that he has heard, preferences being given to those given on 6 May 1940 and 29 September 1952. The Maestro inserted additional work for the timpanist in the fourth movement which Cantelli followed (in toto for this performances with the NBC Symphony Orchetra but only partially for his commercial recording).The outstanding feature of that commercial recording is that he does nothing which detracts from the music – as the critic (MM) in The Gramophone put it (July 1954) there is

a studied avoidance of abnormality. The music is presented, both phrase by phrase and in the build-up of the phrases into the shape of a movement, in exactly the way one feels that Brahms wanted, and indeed specified within the limitations that any score has of being specific.

When Karajan recorded the symphony with the Philharmonia Orchestra (the second of his six commercial recordings) in 1952 it was once described as a gemütlich view of the work: it certainly does not possess the drive and passion of a Toscanini performance (does any?) and the introduction of rallentandi deprives some of the symphony’s strength. The author attended the 1954 Edinburgh Festival with the main purpose of hearing the three concerts to be conducted by Cantelli and he also heard Karajan conduct this symphony. Between the author’s seat in the Usher Hall and the conductor was a young person who was continually shaking his head during the Brahms (his presence had not been noticed earlier in the programme) – whether from approval or displeasure was difficult to ascertain – that individual turned out to be Guido Cantelli.


Cantelli’s Commercial Recording and Recorded Broadcasts

1 Un poco sostenuto – Allegro
Andante sostento
Un poco allegretto e grazioso
Adagio – Più andante – Allegro non troppo ma con brio – Più allegro

    1 2 3 4

Cantelli/NBC Symphony Orchestra

6 December 1952





Cantelli/Philharmonia Orchestra

21 & 22 May 1953





Cantelli/Boston Symphony Orch

28 February 1954





Cantelli/Philharmonic-Symphony Orchestra of New York

20 March 1955






Cantelli gave more performances of this work – 43 – than any other and had he survived that horrific aircrash on his way to New York four more performances would have been added. As can be seen from the table above, movements 1, 2 and 4 tended to be quicker than his commercial recording.

© Keith Bennett 2009


Keith Bennett is the author of Guido Cantelli – Just Eight Years of Fame (published 2009) which is only available from GC Publishers. For further details either write to GC Publishers, 21 Nunn Close, Martlesham, Woodbridge, Suffolk IP12 4UL, UK or e-mail






Find out more:


CD covers to print:
(NB. Disable Page Scaling before printing)

PASC237 cover

CD-writing cuesheet (save as .cue):
(Use this to split MP3 files - see here)

Cue sheet

Download our Full Discography
Printable text listings of all Pristine Audio historic releases
XR remastering by Andrew Rose:
Pristine Audio

Product Tags

Use spaces to separate tags. Use single quotes (') for phrases.

Write Your Own Review

Only registered users can write reviews. Please, log in or register