Pristine Classical e-Newsletter - Click here to subscribe

Pristine News: Friday 28th May, 2010


Schnitger Organ, Cappel (detail)

Detail from the Schnitger Organ at Cappel, Germany



In this week's newsletter:
  • New this week - Astonishing restoration of Walcha's 1950/2 Bach organ recordings
  • New this week - Schillings tackles early Romantic repertoire, including Beethoven's 6th
  • Editorial - More on the recreation of the Cappel church acoustics and its effect for the listener
  • PADA - Part Four of The History of the Cello: "English - Irish Group"
  • Recent Reviews:
    Mark Hambourg's Concerto recordings

    - "a tour de force on several levels despite the limits of the early sound technology"
    Mitropoulos conducts Mendelssohn Symphonies, Gould
    - "Mitropoulos admirers ... will find their conductor on energized form throughout, to put it mildly"





Editorial - The curious effects of convolution reverb

I've written some quite extensive notes for this week's Bach Organ Music release discussing the restoration and remastering process, and in particular my decision to take the unprecedented step of issuing the recording as an Ambient Stereo-only release.

If anything, the release ought perhaps to be designated 'Ambient Stereo Extra' (or something similar), as it's quite radically more 'stereo' than the usual effect of this processing.

I thought long and hard about this decision and finally decided I needed to have the courage of my convictions. For those who do not wish to hear these recordings complete with such processing intervention there is of course the Archiv/DG CD issue of Walcha's later 'real' stereo recordings; for myself I don't think I could listen to the older mono recordings in any other manner, having heard the results here.

I've written a little about the mysteries of what's called 'convolution reverberation' before in these editorials and in my notes. The underlying concept is in some respects quite simple to understand: a sound engineer takes recording equipment to a venue and sets microphones up at an optimal seating or listening position. A single impulse sound, a little like the clap of your hands but electronically generated to contain equal quantities of all frequencies, is played through very high quality loudspeakers (typically B&W 801s), normally positioned centre-stage.

This noise is picked up, together with all of the reflected sound, by the microphones (which can be set up for mono, stereo or surround sound) and a high quality digital recording is made. What happens next is slightly more complicated: the recorded audio is split into direct sound, early reflections, and general reverberant decay, then analysed to generate a file which contains all of the reverberation information (across all the frequencies) for that specific location - in other words, the 'sound' of the building itself is captured and stored.

This data can then be 'convolved' with a new sound recording to reproduce precisely what would be heard by a listener sitting at the location of the microphones in the original venue, when listening to a performance taking place on the stage where the loudspeakers had earlier been placed.

OK, so that's the technical theory bit. I've already written about how fabulously real this can sound in practice – I particularly like the acoustics of the auditoria at Santa Cecilia in Rome. But a church has a very different 'sound', and it's this which has particularly excited me this week.

Unlike an concert hall; churches aren't usually designed principally for their acoustic properties (generally they have higher purposes in mind!). As a result they're often full of hard, reflective surfaces at unusual angles; there are nooks and crannies, vaults, columns, possibly statues and side-chapels, with a lot of hard stone and wood. All of these contribute to the unique acoustics of a church. Some surfaces will reflect certain frequencies better than others; some lower frequencies may boom slightly as standing waves are generated in different parts of the building, some will enhance particular notes when sitting in particular places or appear to redirect sounds away from their source - it's a little like an acoustic "hall of mirrors".

The result for the listener is a bizarre yet wonderful experience. The sound of an organ (which itself may include pipes placed at different locations around the church or cathedral) appears to entirely envelop the listener. And yet, depending on exactly where one sits, certain notes – usually in the upper registers – will appear to have great directionality; the reflection of a particular frequency from a particular part of the structure may suggest what is in effect an artificial 'stereo' location. Notes can appear almost to jump around in the air, as different reflections give different illusions of source, even though these may be entirely divorced from the actual position of the organ pipe that's sounding at the time.

Whereas traditional electronic reverberation systems create a random diffusion of sound, the convolution reverb has precisely mapped all of the acoustic idiosyncrasies of a building, and these are played out again when a new recording source is 'convolved' with the building's acoustic file, as I've already described.

Thus with Helmut Walcha's Bach. By using acoustic data from a church with very similar dimensions and interior characteristics to that where the recording was made, we get a very good idea of the sound of the organ for one seated within that church at Cappel, Germany (bearing in mind that just about every seat on every pew in the church will offer a different listening perspective and experience). Some upper notes do appear to have real directionality. Certain lower resonances do excite standing waves and boom very slightly. The very lowest notes have such a depth, resonance and majesty that it's almost impossible to believe they originated in the grooves of a sixty-year-old LP...

Every recording is effectively an artificial construct – some far more than others (witness the half-speed rifle shots dubbed into Kenneth Alwyn's excellent stereo Decca 1812 Overture to represent cannon fire) – and in some cases these artificialities are entirely unwarranted. In the case of Helmut Walcha's early Bach recordings with the addition of convolution reverb, however, I believe the results speak for themselves – and after four weeks of listening to them I'm still astonished at what could be achieved and delighted with the results.



Andrew Rose













New release today:

BACH Orgel-Büchlein
Pristine Audio PAKM 036

CD ArtworkHelmut Walcha, organ
Recorded in 1950 and 1952

Recorded June 1950 and September 1952, producer Dr E Thienhaus
Transfers from Archiv LPs APM 14021, 14022 and 14030 
XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, May 2010
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Helmut Walcha

Total duration: 1 hr 39:24 
©2010 Pristine Audio.

An Ambient Stereo Release (see notes below)


For more download and CD options, see our website

Ambient Stereo FLAC downloads
16-bit Mono FLAC
24-bit FLAC


An astonishing organ experience from Helmut Walcha

Early mono LP recordings completely transformed for this special release

 

"Bach opens a vista to the universe. 
After experiencing him, people feel there is meaning to life after all."

- Helmut Walcha

 

  • J. S. BACH Orgel-Büchlein - Choral Preludes 1-45, BWV 599-644 [notes / score]
    Recorded June 1950 and September 1952. 
    Produced by Dr. Erich Thienhaus
    Issued as Archiv LPs APM 14021 & 14022

  • J. S. BACH Canonic Variations on 'Von Himmel hoch, da komm ich her', BWV 769a [notes / score]
  • J. S. BACH Meine Seele erhabt den Herren (Magnificat), BWV 733
    Recorded 9th, 20th & 21st June 1950. 
    Produced by Dr. Erich Thienhaus
    Issued as Archiv LPs APM 14030

    Helmut Walcha, Schnitger Organ, Capell, Germany 

     

    Brief history of the Cappel Organ

    1680
    : New organ by Arp Schnitger for the Johannis Kirche in Hamburg. Pipework from a former organ was used and perhaps also parts of the case.
    Schnitger Organ at Cappel
    Schnitger Organ, Cappel

    1816: Georg Wilhelmy moved the organ to Cappel.

    1939: Restoration by Paul Ott.

    1978: Restoration by von Beckerath after damage by a new heating system. The original frontpipes still are present. They were "forgotten" in 1917.

    Specification:

    Hauptwerk

     

    Rückpositif

     

    Pedal

     

    Quintadena

    16'

    Gedact

    8'

    Untersatz

    16'

    Principal

    8'

    Quintadena

    8'

    Octava

    8'

    Hollfloit

    8'

    Principal

    4'

    Octava

    4'

    Octava

    4'

    Floit

    4'

    Nachthorn

    2'

    Spitzfloit

    4'

    Octava

    2'

    Rauschpfeiffe

    II

    Nasat

    2 2/3'

    Siffloit

    1 1/3'

    Mixtur IV-VI

    Gemshorn

    2'

    Tertian

    II

    Posaun

    16'

    Rauschpfeiffe

    II

    Sesquialtera

    II

    Trompet 8'

    Mixtur

    V-VI

    Scharff

    IV-VI

    Cornet

    2'

    Cimbel (01) III

    Dulcian

    16'

       

    Trompet

    8'

           

    2009: Restoration of the bellows by Beckerath.

    [Information from www.arpschnitger.nl]

 


BACH: Organ Music Double-CD

Helmut Walcha's Bach organ recordings set the gold standard for the repertoire, having recorded just about all of them twice - all the more remarkable for the fact that the organist was blind from the age of nineteen.

His earlier, mono recordings have been somewhat neglected in favour of his slightly later stereo re-takes. This astonishing restoration aims to reset the balance: It takes a series of recordings made in 1950 and 1952 in the church of Cappel in Germany and aims to completely rejuvenate them, capturing not only the full glory of the 1680 Schnitger organ, but also - thanks to an advanced Ambient Stereo process - recreating the full sonic effect of the building itself. This really has to be heard to be believed!


 Sample MP3
Preludes 3, 4, 5 & 6
(Ambient Stereo)


Notes on the Transfers:

Keyboard
Organ Console, Cappel

Helmut Walcha's Bach recordings are rightly hailed as some of the greatest of the twentieth century. He recorded more or less the complete organ music twice for DG – the first time around (1947-52) in mono, and then again a few short years later (1956-71), remaking the series in stereo. As a result the mono recordings soon slipped into a kind of semi-obscurity, with later reissues concentrating on the stereo equivalents.

There is some kind of sense in this for the listener – by comparison to the potentially room-filling and awe-inspiring sound of a church organ and its attendant acoustics which envelop you when listening to stereo recordings, it seems to me that more than usual is somehow lost in a mono organ recording; the instrument seems considerably diminished, the impact distant, one-dimensional and uninspiring.

This was the sound I heard coming from my speakers when I started transferring the first of five LP sides which together made up the source material for this release (the sixth side featured older recordings of a different organ), and I was deeply ambivalent with regard to the possibilities offered by the recordings. It was more through a sense curiosity than any real hope that I began experimenting with the restoration and remastering of such unlikely work – and a feeling that Pristine really had managed to neglect the organ repoertoire over the last five or so years.

The first sign that all was considerably better than I at first thought came with XR re-equalisation – by now the minor irritants of vinyl surface noise had already been dealt with and I saw immediately from the frequency response curve that much musical information had probably been somewhat buried by poor recording equipment. In particular the magnificent lower registers of the organ were often muted to the extent that they were barely audible; restoring these to their more normal levels had literally ground-shaking consequences! Further up the frequency range and there again was more to be heard than the records ever suggested – with XR re-equalisation what was beginning to emerge suggested something of the full grandeur of the instrument itself.

Detail
Schnitger Organ Detail, Cappel

I still had a problem, however. One of the great aspects of listening to a church or cathedral organ is the effect the building's acoustics have on the sound experience, as one is enveloped in sound which appears to arrive from all directions and none at the same time. This seemed more than Pristine's Ambient Stereo processing normally delivers, so I turned instead to the option of using advanced convolution reverberation. This takes the acoustic 'sound' of a real location and maps it digitally, allowing the reverberation from that space to be used in an exceptionally realistic manner for other recordings.

Although I did not have an acoustic mapping of the church used for this recording, what I did have in my collection was a remarkably similar church. The village church of Cappel, in which stands the beautiful Schnitger Organ heard here, is rather small and unassuming – its shorter reverberant decay time blurs the music less and allows one to hear much more fine finger-work than might be apparent in a larger church or cathedral. By mixing in a small amount of convolution reverb derived from a very similarly sized and constructed church I was able to take this recording a final step closer to reality and realise the full sense of presence and place captured in the grooves of those 60 year-old LPs.

In fact, so convinced am I that this recording really needs this additional 'help' that I've taken the unprecedented step of offering it only as an Ambient Stereo recording – in all formats. Without it the recordings seemed (to me) somewhat ineffectual and dusty relics, superseded by their later re-recordings. With it they're truly alive and astonishingly vivid and contemporary – given full rein and a good bass response from your loudspeakers the grander works are truly awe-inspiring to hear, while the more contemplative pieces completely hold the attention. In short, I'm delighted and just a little overwhelmed by what has been possible here – as I hope you will be too.

Andrew Rose

 

 

 

Available as 320kbps Ambient Stereo MP3, 16-bit Ambient Stereo FLAC, 24-bit Ambient Stereo FLAC, Ambient Stereo CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)







New release today:

Pristine Audio PASC 228

CD ArtworkBerlin State Opera Orchestra
conducted by Max von Schillings 

Recorded in 1928 and 1929

Producer and Audio Restoration Engineer: Mark Obert-Thorn
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Max von Schillings

Total duration: 77:59 
©2010 Pristine Audio



For more download and CD options, see our website


The downloads:

Ambient Stereo FLAC

16-bit Mono FLAC


A superb range of early Romantic works conducted by Schillings

Teacher of Furtwängler, composer and conductor, in excellent new transfers

 
  • WEBER Euryanthe - Overture (8:48) [notes / score]
    Recorded 8th October, 1928 in Berlin 
    Matrix nos.: 2-20991 through 2-20993 
    First issued on Parlophon P-9848 and 9849


  • WEBER Abu Hassan - Overture (3:27) [notes / score]
    Recorded 19th December, 1928 in Berlin 
    Matrix no.: 2-21137 
    First issued on Parlophon P-9849 


  • SCHUMANN Manfred, Op. 115 - Overture [notes / score]
  • SCHUMANN Manfred, Op. 115 - Alpenkuhreigen und Zwischenaktmusik* (3:59) [notes / score]
    Recorded 3rd May and *10th May, 1929 in Berlin 
    Matrix nos.: 2-21393 through 2-21395, and *2-21406 
    First issued on Parlophon P-9484 and 9485 


  • BEETHOVEN Egmont, Op. 84 - Overture (8:01) [notes / score]
    Recorded 14th December, 1928 in Berlin 
    Matrix nos.: 2-21126 and 2-21127 
    First issued on Parlophon P-9456 


  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 6 in F Major, Op. 68 (“Pastoral”) (42:50) [notes / score]
    Recorded 16th, 23rd and 30th September, 1929 in Berlin 
    Matrix nos.: 2-21560 through 2-21566; 2-21572 and 2-21573; and 2-21586 through 2-21588 
    First issued on Parlphon P-9463 through 9468 


    Berlin State Opera Orchestra
    conducted by Max von Schillings


BEETHOVEN: Pastoral Symphony & Romantic Overtures

For his May release Mark Obert-Thorn's done it again! Delving deep into his vast collection of exquisite 78rpm discs he's unearthed another collection of superb yet neglected recordings from the late 1920s.

Max von Schillings was a mainstay of the German music establishment for most of his life, as composer, conductor and teacher (his most famous pupil being the great Furtwängler), yet recordings of his performances on CD have generally concentrated on his own compositions.

Here we find him with the orchestra he led for many years, tackling a delightful variety of early Romantic works - for the first time on CD.


Sample MP3
Schumann - Manfred Overture


Notes on the recording:

The few CD reissues devoted to recordings of Max von Schillings which have appeared so far have concentrated on his justly-acclaimed Wagner performances, as well as those of his own compositions (Mona Lisa, Das Hexenlied). This release aims to broaden our appreciation of his abilities with a program of early Romantic repertoire.

The sources for the transfers were American Columbia “Viva-Tonal” pressings for the Weber items; American “Okeh” Odeons (also pressed by American Columbia during their “Viva-Tonal” period) for the Schumann tracks; a pre-EMI laminated British Parlophone for the Egmont; and Italian Parlophon pressings (with a couple patches from a German Odeon set) for the Pastoral Symphony. Although the original engineering was not state-of-the-art for its time, the recordings from the 1928-29 season appear to have less overloading and blasting than the symphony, taken down the following season.

Mark Obert-Thorn


 

Available as 320kbps MP3, 16-bit mono FLAC, CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)




New MP3 transfers at PADA Exclusives
by Dr. John Duffy
in Ambient Stereo

History of the Cello
Vol. 4: "English - Irish Group" 

Felix Salmond
Felix Salmond

Featuring Cellists:
Felix Salmond
W. H. Squire
Victor Herbert 


 

Part of a ten-volume series charting the historic recordings of cello music in the 78rpm era, replete with rare and important recordings by the greatest players of the first half of the 20th Century.


 

This History of the Cello series follows our earlier PADA Exclusives presentation of collections from the Thomas Clear limited edition LP transfer releases, for which we can now also supply scans of Clear-s original typewritten notes:

History of Chamber Music:


 

History of the Violin:


 

This transfer is presented with Ambient Stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy.

Over 400 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers.

Remastered by 
Dr John Duffy
In Ambient Stereo

 




Download or stream this recording and many others from only One Euro a week!

Hundreds of historic recordings are available for listening and free MP3 download
  to subscribers to PADA Exclusives, our €1/week streamed audio service.


Other subscription offers give you full access to our entire online catalogue




Pick of the reviews



BEETHOVEN: Piano Concerto No. 3 in C Minor, Op. 37
TCHAIKOVSKY: Piano Concerto No. 1 in B-flat Minor, OP. 23
Mark Hambourg, piano
London Symphony Orchestra /Malcolm Sargent (Beethoven)
Royal Albert Hall Orchestra/Landon Ronald (Tchaikovsky)

Pristine Audio PASC 223, 63:28 [4 stars]


Mark Hambourg (1879-1960) has faded into relative oblivion, despite his having at one time dominated the musical scene in Britain after he and his family emigrated from Tsarist Russia. Hambourg stopped cutting commercial discs after 1935. Brought to the attention of Paderewski, Hambourg went on to study with Leschetitzky in Vienna who purified and refined his sound. These transcriptions of shellacs made in Kingsway Hall, London give us the only concerto recordings Hambourg inscribed, the Beethoven C Minor (13-14 November 1929) and the Tchaikovsky First Concerto (28 September 1926), the concerto’s first electrical recording and never prior-issued on LP or CD. The transfers by Mark Obert-Thorn are relatively quiet, given the noisy surface quality of the originals.

What we glean from the Beethoven is a rather willful, Romantic manner of execution, often disregarding Beethoven’s explicit tempo and dynamic markings and then interpolating--in the cadenza--all sorts of playful and improvisational asides, curlicues, and repeated notes. The slowings-down and speedings-up at random passages seem, if not frivolous, at the very least matters of artistic license few contemporary artists would dare. Still, Hambourg can project a lovely tone and shades of nuance when he wishes, and his “vocal” palette elicits enough pearly play to justify Busoni’s contention that in the early part of the 20th Century, Hambourg was the greatest active talent of his time. The case for intellectual and digital refinement appears in the Largo movement, which holds the plastic line in fine balance. The right hand fioritura and trills prove elegant and clearly articulate. The opening of the last movement suffers a bit of dry acoustic, but the tonal and dynamic refinement shines through. The delicacy of performance rather takes us aback, its fluid lightness almost suggestive of the last movement of the Grieg Concerto rather than of Beethoven. Rocket like flurries mark the last flourish to the coda, scintillating and brilliant in their ravishing surface energy.

Obert-Thorn admits in his liner notes that the first side of the Tchaikovsky Concerto needed a new take, given its distant sonic perspective; I find the piano sound muddy and unfocused. Hambourg likely packed some devastating double octaves, but they are mystified by the primitive technology, which also clouds his bass. Ronald himself indulges in some old-world portamento and slides, but the massive shape of the first movement remains firm. That Hambourg commanded a poetic sensibility comes through in the lyrical sections of movement, and his rapid passagework attests to a striking digital finesse. Hambourg does not shy away from some demonic fioritura when the impulse grabs him; he then segues into ravishing light touches that well anticipate the more monolithic contrasts effected by Sviatoslav Richter. The cadenza has Hambourg applying some high-octave interpolations that are pure poetic license. The second movement moves with a silken poise appropriate to any age of pianism, the waltz-sequence taking on a dreamy charm in the manner of a polichinelle from one of the composer’s ballets. The last movement canters rather than thunders, opening moderato, with the “con fuoco” gathering itself incrementally. When Hambourg does accelerate through Ronald’s slides, he demonstrates broad, sweeping gestures, a sylvan assurance that can easily explode with obsessive force. The last pages might have been played by the young Horowitz, so tempestuous are the upward scales to the coda, which resounds with a Russian verve all its own. Quite a rare ride, a tour de force on several levels despite the limits of the early sound technology.

--Gary Lemco



MUSICWEB INTERNATIONAL


Felix MENDELSSOHN (1809-1847)
Symphony No.3 in A minor, Op.56 Scottish (1829-42) [31:51]
Symphony No.5 in D minor, Op.107, Reformation (1829-30) [27:47]
Morton GOULD (1913-1996)
Philharmonic Waltzes (1947-48) [9:25]

Philharmonic-Symphony Orchestra of New York/Dimitri Mitropoulos
rec. 2 November 1953 (Mendelssohn) and 23 January 1950 (Gould); Columbia 30th Street Studio, New York


PRISTINE AUDIO PASC 187
[68:591]

Mitropoulos set down these two Mendelssohn symphonies in a hurry. They were both recorded on 2 November 1953 and he was in no mood to stretch out like a cat arching its back in front of the fire. No, indeed, the Greek conductor was a beast of altogether a different stamp, launching a tigerish dive on perceived pieties in these works and driving his way through them.

He certainly takes the con moto indication seriously in the opening Andante section of the Scottish, vesting it with rhythmic snap and directionality. It then takes off with a surging, almost breathless vitality. The storm-pressed moments of the symphony are conveyed with huge drama but whilst the slow movement is sympathetically articulated its very terse sense of movement tends only to promote one rather doctrinaire approach to the score. The original recording was apparently - I’ve never heard it - very boxy and the gaps between movements extremely small. The former seems to have attended to via XR opening out, but the latter has been left ‘as is’.

The companion Reformation symphony conveys a similar sense of power and speed, though of a markedly less extreme kind. So the tensile qualities here sound rather more formal and acceptable and emerge as a taut and drama-laced (rather than merely driven) performance. Once again, though, Mitropoulos’s avoidance of extraneous romantic gesture means the reading is quite determinist and those unsympathetic to his way with it will recoil from the occasional ferocity.

As a pendant we have a recording from 1953 of Morton Gould’s Philharmonic Waltzes, a 1947 commission. This alternates between perky and pawky, and takes in a wide and bustling range of influences - a long list amongst whom Milhaud, Bernstein, and Strausses Richard (primarily) and Johann might find themselves numbered. It’s finely played by the NYPSO.

This disc handily collates the two Mendelssohn performances, which will be the motor of interest for Mitropoulos admirers. They will find their conductor on energized form throughout, to put it mildly.

Jonathan Woolf 



NOTE: This e-mail is going out to our most recently compiled mailing list of recent customers and existing list members. If you do not wish to receive any further e-mails from Pristine Classical please contact me directly by e-mail at this address and I'll remove your address from our list immediately. Alternatively click here to unsubscribe - please ensure you reply from the same e-mail address that this mailing was sent to.


--
Andrew Rose
Pristine Classical
www.pristineclassical.com

 

 

Google
 
Web Pristine Classical

 

 

Pristine Classical - DRM-free historic FLAC and MP3 downloads since 2005