The
Philadelphia Orchestra
Conductor: Leopold Stokowski Recorded
12th November, 1934.
Issued in the UK as 5 HMV 78s, D.B.2548-D.B.2853
Download ID: 125756/432797
Duration 46'13"
Play
sample movement:
To
call Stokoswki legendary is almost an understatement. Always an
innovator, always prepared to question, to court controversy and to search
for excellence, he was without doubt one of the greatest conductors of
all time.
Stokowski
single-handedly turned the Philadelphia Orchestra into one of the world's
greatest during his time with them between 1911 and 1941, and the legacy
of that can be heard here in this astounding recording of TchaIkovsky's
Fifth Symphony, recorded in 1934 and now sounding stunning in this brand
new remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio.
Unusually
for any 78rpm recording this appears to have been recorded in a single
take - or at least a movement at a time, rather than the more conventional
one-side-at-a-time approach. This gives the whole performance a greater
degree of coherence and inevitability - a far cry from modern techniques
where some conductors record literally a bar at a time to edit together
afterwards.
This
is surely one of the great historic recordings of all time - if you don't
have it you should get it - if you do have it, well perhaps it's never
sounded better that it does here!
REVIEW
OF TCHAIKOVSKY'S SYMPHONY NO. 5 IN E MINOR
Philadelphia Orchesta, conducted by Leopold Stokowski (1934)
Tschaikowsky
was on tour about to rehearse his new symphony (#5) in Hamburg
(Spring, 1889) when he discovered that Johannes Brahms was occupying
the same hotel. At previous meetings, they had been cordial
to each other, but they did not like each others' music. Brahms,
however, postponed his departure in order to hear the rehearsal
of the Tschaikowky. At a well-lubricated dinner afterwards,
Brahms said he liked the first three movements, but did not
care for the finale. Tschaikowsky, who in letters to his patroness,
Madame von Meck, had already rather excoriated the symphony,
was somewhat buoyed up by Brahms' judgment.
We
may speculate on what Brahms, a masterful finale composer,
disliked about the finale of the 5th symphony. It begins with
the symphony's motto (which starts the symphony in a doleful
E minor) now played rather majestically in E major. In the
major key, it sounds a bit artificial and rather bombastic
and it goes on without much incident for a while. Thankfully,
it segues into one of Tschaikowsky's most dashing and brilliantly
breathless allegros which is the heart of the movement and
is filled with glorious melody and incident. Ultimately to
end the movement and the symphony, Tschaikowsky goes back
to a very martial version of the motto theme. Here he tries
to create maximum triumph, but takes a long time to end things
using every delaying tactic in his "coitus interruptus"
manner before ending the work. The problem for the conductor
is to sustain the genuine excitement of the long middle section
through the somewhat artificial excitement of the final section
to get to the blessed final note. Let's see how Stokowsky
in his prime (1934) makes out.
Stokowsky
begins the Symphony with a sad but firm statement of the motto
theme and a controlled but beautiful statement of the lovely
second theme. No wallowing and no distortion. An excellent
playing of the development follows, almost convincing us that
Tschaikowsky knew how to develop a theme (not until the first
movement of the Pathetique does he show what might have been
if only he hadn't drunk that glass of unboiled water). Stokowsky
almost ruins things by presenting the recapitulation of the
motto them too slowly but recovers to end the movement well.
Both
Tschaikowsky and Stokowsky are magnificent in the incredibly
beautiful second movement. Stokowsky refuses to just float
in the blue sea of melody and keeps a tight rein until nearly
the end when his and the Philadelphia's letting go has an
enormous effect. The fresh and dewy playing of the orchestra
in the third movement almost entirely conceals this movement's
lack of stature.
Stokowsky's
performance of the finale pokes holes in my expectations from
above. He begins the first section at a moderate tempo and
achieves a certain valedictory air. Not what I was expecting,
but not too bad. Now, I'm ready for the allegro and a rather
brutal chase. It doesn't come. Stokowsky conducts a very competent,
but not terribly exciting allegro, filled with very good brass
incidents. And now I'm a bit disappointed and dreading the
final peroration. When it comes, however, it seems to have
a lot of energy on its own without any help from the middle
movement and I quite enjoy it. I ride it to the end with little
sense of bombast. I still miss the central allegro, but I
conclude that all in all this is a rather fine performance
of Tschaikowsky's Fifth Symphony.
My
only reference to the reproduction that I am very fond of
1950's mono sound and here is another example of it.
Reviewer:
Bill Rosen
Restorer's
clarification:
Bill's reference to "1950's mono sound" apparently
refers back to a previous review
where he lavished praise on a 1927 recording I'd remastered.
The implication is that it sounds a lot better than one might
expect!
Download
our Illustrated Catalogue Complete
catalogue of recordings, fully indexed by composer and performer,
with links to website pages
Restoration
by Andrew Rose:
ADVERTISEMENT
Pristine Classical - bringing you DRM-free classical MP3 downloads
FAQ
FLAC downloads use lossless compression - when replayed or transferred to disc they are bit- identical to original recordings.
16 BIT files are at full CD resolution, identical to our CD masters.
24 BIT files are at higher, studio master resolution, identical to our finished master files.
Please ensure you can play our 24 bit FLAC files before purchase - try our test files here.
Not all media players support FLAC yet, so you may need to convert to WAV or AIFF before playback. See our FLAC help guide
FLAC downloads come as a series of tracks in a ZIP archive file.
Our MP3 files are encoded at very high variable bitrates using the LAME encoder, widely regarded as the offering the best sound quality
Each recording is presented as a single, long MP3 which can be split using the CUE sheet at the bottom of the page, adding track titles and other information.
CD writing programs such as Nero and Burrrn can write these files directly to CD with all track information added using MP3+CUE - see our tutorial
Alternatively a cue splitter program can automatically cut and name the MP3 into individual MP3 tracks
There are also media players which use the MP3+CUE system, allowing gapless playback of all long MP3 files - essential for opera and many other classical works
Save money when you buy several downloads together by using the following discount codes in the shopping cart:
Buy 5 or more - save 10%: Code: 85187052
Buy 10 or more - save 20%: Code: 12W07104
How To Use: Once you've made your selections, copy the correct code into the space marked Discount or Coupon Code in your shopping cart, then click the Update Cart button to apply the discount before heading to the checkout.
N.B. These discounts apply to all our FLAC and MP3 downloads only. Discounts do not apply to CD purchases
Our CDs are made to order on highest quality Taiyo Yuden Watershield CD-R discs, recorded directly from our master files
CDs are shipped worldwide by Air Mail from France. The price here includes all shipping costs - there are no hidden extras
Standard and Premium CDs hold the same quality of audio - the Standard CD comes in a slip case with no covers, the Premium comes in a jewel case with printed covers
Each music page has PDF covers for printing out at home
They can be found by clicking on cover artwork or scrolling to the bottom of the page
Always deselect any resizing options in the print dialogue of Adobe Reader before printing to ensure correct cover sizes
All payments are processed by PayPal, one of the world's biggest and most reliable global online payment services
You can pay by credit card directly with PayPal acting merely as a secure card payment processing facility
You can use a PayPal account for quicker, easier and totally secure payments
We do not recommend using the e-check option for download purchases as there is always a delay of 3-4 working days between purchase and receipt of goods while the check clears
Payments are charged in Euros and will be converted from other currencies at the current PayPal exchange rate
