BBC
Symphony Orchestra,
Conductor: Sir Adrian Boult Recorded
in the Corn Exchange, Bedford, 2nd-5th Jan 1945.,
Released as HMV D.B.6227-D.B.6233 & D.B.S.6229
Download ID: 98176/432792
Duration 46'45"
Play
sample movement:
This
latest makeover, much the best so far, is from... Pristine Audio...
Piers Burton-Page, BBC Radio 3, 6/8/05
Sir
Adrian Boult was at the centre of British musical life for many years,
and it was as conductor of the BBC Symphony Orchestra that he first achieved
international fame. However, way back in 1919, at the composer's request,
it was Boult who conducted the first performance of parts of Holst's
suite, The Planets, a work which was destined to become the composer's
most well known piece and bring him, too, international fame and recognition.
Boult
was also a powerful advocate for British music, conducting many performances
and recordings of works by both well-known and lesser-known composers,
and thus was in the perfect position to deliver definitive recordings
of the great works of the British repertoire - one only has to listen
to his 1949 delivery of Elgar's first symphony (PASC003)
on this site to appreciate his talents. A quick listen to our new restoration
will reveal what a gem has been uncovered from this wartime recording,
especially now we've filtered out background sounds in the last few sides
- which resembled the distant rumble of heavy aircraft flying overhead!
REVIEW
OF PRISTINE AUDIO RELEASES OF "THE PLANETS"
Conducted by Sir Adrian Boult (1945) and Sir Malcolm Sargeant
(1954)
The
immense popularity of Gustav Holst's "The Planets"
as an audiophile showpiece has blinded us to the fact that
it is a great piece of music. It has the melody, the orchestration,
the drive, and the variety that none of his other works--not
the English sunday school flavors of the "Choral Symphony"
or "Choral Fantasy" nor the pub folksy joys of the
band suites nor the hermetic eastern mysticisms of "Savitri"
or the "Rig Veda Hymns"--possess. These two recording,
both taken down closer in time to the work's composition than
I am to their recording, re-affirm for me the Planet's magic
in a way that modern recordings do not. Why that is, I do
not know. I do know that the audio restorations have afforded
me great pleasure and brought a tear to my eye more than once.
The two recording are very different and I will compare them
movement by
movement:
MARS: Boult's Mars starts out with very detailed, detache
strings and reserved brass and works up to a great crescendo;
the effect is very menacing. Sargent starts out with fairly
strong brass, with strings more in the background; the effect
is warlike, but not as menacing as Boult. Sargent has the
better sound throughout, but Boult through his tightness seems
to bring greater intensity. In the rushing quavers leading
to the hammer-blows at the end, Boult projects a crushing
sense of tragic inevitability while Sargent gives us a lot
of excitement. Even with poorer sound Boult wins, but not
by as much as I'd have imagined.
VENUS: Sargent was supposed to have a way with the fairer
sex and so he certainly does here. Even allowing for his finer
sound, Sargent's Venus is far superior to Boult's. His langorous
oboe and flute, the sensuous strings, the tempi are so gorgeous
as to make Boult's Venus someone sitting at the phone waiting
for a call from her teen-aged boyfriend.
MERCURY: Sargent's Mercury is brilliant in the percussion
area, but a little heavywight in the strings. Tempi are slow.
Boult's version is lean, very fast, somehow more forward moving
and just more (dare we say) mercurial?
JUPITER: Both Boult and Sargent play Jupiter magnificently;
neither sentimentalize nor slow up at the great Elgarish tune;
both are lean and fast. It is left to later foreign conductors
to inject avoirdupois into this piece. Sargent's finer sound
causes me to prefer his version. Neither version can capture
the magnificent subterranean billowing strings upwelling near
the end; that required future technology.
SATURN: Saturn can bring anti-climax as well as old age. Neither
is brought by Sargent. He gives the greatest performance in
either set of "The Planets" to Saturn. It is hard
to describe as it brought a tear to my eye: the power and
inevitability of the opening chords, the anguish and the warmth
and serenity of the closing I've never experienced before.
Boult in his grimness and austerity is swept away.
URANUS: Here Boult is brilliant. The central, mocking march
is made to be so arrogant and cocksure that one must chuckle.
Sargent cannot summon the same degree of cheek.
NEPTUNE: I fear that Sargent doesn't understand this music;
neither do I. But Boult does and he makes me appreciate it.
It's not just a salad of sonorities; it really conveys an
otherworldly feeling under Boult's baton.
Well,
in summary, it's almost impossible to choose between the two,
which is surprising given Boult's and Sargent's contemporary
reputations. Sargent has, in the Pristine Audio remastering,
by far the best sound. Boult wins, by a slight margin, musically.
Sargent gives the single greatest performance ("Saturn").
I intend to get them both. They have something that Bernstein
and Karajan don't.
Download
our Illustrated Catalogue Complete
catalogue of recordings, fully indexed by composer and performer,
with links to website pages
Restoration
by Andrew Rose:
ADVERTISEMENT
Pristine Classical - bringing you DRM-free classical MP3 downloads
FAQ
FLAC downloads use lossless compression - when replayed or transferred to disc they are bit- identical to original recordings.
16 BIT files are at full CD resolution, identical to our CD masters.
24 BIT files are at higher, studio master resolution, identical to our finished master files.
Please ensure you can play our 24 bit FLAC files before purchase - try our test files here.
Not all media players support FLAC yet, so you may need to convert to WAV or AIFF before playback. See our FLAC help guide
FLAC downloads come as a series of tracks in a ZIP archive file.
Our MP3 files are encoded at very high variable bitrates using the LAME encoder, widely regarded as the offering the best sound quality
Each recording is presented as a single, long MP3 which can be split using the CUE sheet at the bottom of the page, adding track titles and other information.
CD writing programs such as Nero and Burrrn can write these files directly to CD with all track information added using MP3+CUE - see our tutorial
Alternatively a cue splitter program can automatically cut and name the MP3 into individual MP3 tracks
There are also media players which use the MP3+CUE system, allowing gapless playback of all long MP3 files - essential for opera and many other classical works
Save money when you buy several downloads together by using the following discount codes in the shopping cart:
Buy 5 or more - save 10%: Code: 85187052
Buy 10 or more - save 20%: Code: 12W07104
How To Use: Once you've made your selections, copy the correct code into the space marked Discount or Coupon Code in your shopping cart, then click the Update Cart button to apply the discount before heading to the checkout.
N.B. These discounts apply to all our FLAC and MP3 downloads only. Discounts do not apply to CD purchases
Our CDs are made to order on highest quality Taiyo Yuden Watershield CD-R discs, recorded directly from our master files
CDs are shipped worldwide by Air Mail from France. The price here includes all shipping costs - there are no hidden extras
Standard and Premium CDs hold the same quality of audio - the Standard CD comes in a slip case with no covers, the Premium comes in a jewel case with printed covers
Each music page has PDF covers for printing out at home
They can be found by clicking on cover artwork or scrolling to the bottom of the page
Always deselect any resizing options in the print dialogue of Adobe Reader before printing to ensure correct cover sizes
All payments are processed by PayPal, one of the world's biggest and most reliable global online payment services
You can pay by credit card directly with PayPal acting merely as a secure card payment processing facility
You can use a PayPal account for quicker, easier and totally secure payments
We do not recommend using the e-check option for download purchases as there is always a delay of 3-4 working days between purchase and receipt of goods while the check clears
Payments are charged in Euros and will be converted from other currencies at the current PayPal exchange rate
This
latest makeover, much the best so far, is from... Pristine Audio...
